Secret HR Tactics Revealed: What Your Boss Really Thinks During Salary Reviews (You Won’t Believe #4)

You walk into that meeting room, palms slightly sweaty, rehearsing your pitch one last time. Your manager sits across from you with a folder, a slight smile, and what feels like all the power in the world. Welcome to salary review season, where your financial future hangs in the balance of a 30-minute conversation.

But here’s what most employees don’t realise: your boss isn’t just evaluating your performance. They’re following a carefully orchestrated process, using specific tactics and frameworks that HR departments have refined over decades. The good news? Once you understand these insider strategies, you can level the playing field.

After analysing recent compensation review research and speaking with HR professionals, we’ve uncovered the tactics that happen behind closed doors. Whether you’re preparing for your annual review or considering a job switch, understanding what your boss really thinks during salary reviews could be worth thousands of pounds to your bottom line.

What Actually Happens Before You Enter That Room

Before you even sit down for your salary review, a complex process has already unfolded. Your manager hasn’t just woken up that morning and decided your worth on a whim. According to industry research on compensation reviews, HR teams typically begin planning salary reviews months in advance, conducting market research, analysing budget constraints, and establishing clear guidelines for raises.

Here’s the reality: your manager has likely attended multiple calibration meetings where they’ve compared your performance against your colleagues. They’ve reviewed salary benchmarking data, consulted with finance about budget allocations, and received specific parameters about what they can and cannot offer.

The process isn’t personal, it’s systematic. And that’s actually good news for you, because systems can be understood and navigated.

HR Tactic #1: The Budget Was Set Months Ago (And It’s Not What You Think)

Let’s start with the uncomfortable truth: by the time you’re sitting in that salary review meeting, the budget for raises has already been determined. Most companies allocate between 3% and 5% of total payroll for annual salary increases, and this decision typically happens at the executive level months before your review.

But here’s where it gets interesting. That budget isn’t distributed equally. Companies divide their salary increase pool into three main categories:

• Inflation adjustments (typically 2-3% across the board)
• Market-based corrections (for roles that have become more competitive)
• Merit increases (performance-based rewards for top contributors)

According to recent salary negotiation statistics, the average salary increase in 2024 was just 4%, down from 6.2% in 2022. This represents a 42% decrease over two years, meaning the pot is getting smaller whilst living costs continue rising.

What your boss is really thinking: “I have £50,000 to distribute amongst my team of 15 people. If I give Sarah a 10% increase, that means less for everyone else. How do I justify my decisions?”

The Three-Bucket System Managers Use

Most managers mentally categorise their team members into three groups during salary reviews:

1. Top performers (10-15% of the team) who receive the largest increases
2. Solid contributors (70-80%) who receive modest, inflation-matching raises
3. Underperformers (5-10%) who may receive minimal or no increase

Understanding which bucket you’re in before the meeting can dramatically change your negotiation strategy.

HR Tactic #2: Your Performance Rating Was Calibrated Against Your Colleagues

You might think your performance review is about you and your manager. It’s not. Before your salary review, your manager participated in what’s called a “calibration session” with other department heads and HR.

In these meetings, managers compare notes on their team members, discussing who deserves top ratings and who doesn’t. The goal is to ensure consistency across the organisation and prevent “rating inflation” where every manager claims their entire team is exceptional.

Research on compensation review processes reveals that these calibration meetings average about three minutes per employee when properly structured. Three minutes to discuss a year’s worth of your contributions.

What your boss is really thinking: “I wanted to rate James as ‘exceptional,’ but HR pushed back because too many people in the department already have that rating. I had to defend my decision for 15 minutes and ultimately compromised on ‘exceeds expectations’ instead.”

The Forced Distribution Curve

Many companies use a forced distribution system, sometimes called “rank and yank,” where managers must fit their team’s performance ratings into a predetermined curve:

• 10% exceptional performers
• 20% above average
• 40% meeting expectations
• 20% below average
• 10% underperforming

This means even if your entire team is brilliant, someone has to be rated as below average. It’s not personal, it’s mathematical.

HR Tactic #3: They’re Comparing You to Market Data You’ve Never Seen

Whilst you’ve been focused on your day-to-day work, HR has been conducting extensive salary benchmarking research. They’re comparing your compensation to industry standards, competitor salaries, and regional market rates using sophisticated tools and databases.

According to compensation management experts, companies now use platforms powered by data from providers like Mercer to analyse market values for specific roles and cross-reference them against current pay structures.

What your boss is really thinking: “According to our benchmarking data, software engineers with five years of experience in London should earn between £65,000 and £85,000. Sarah is currently at £62,000, which puts her below market rate. I need to address this or risk losing her to a competitor.”

The Compa-Ratio Formula

HR professionals use something called a “compa-ratio” to determine if you’re paid fairly. The formula is simple:

Compa-Ratio = (Your Current Salary ÷ Midpoint of Salary Range) × 100

• A ratio of 100 means you’re paid exactly at market midpoint
• Below 80 means you’re significantly underpaid
• Above 120 means you’re at the top of your range

If your compa-ratio is low, you have concrete ammunition for negotiation. If it’s high, your manager may resist giving you a substantial increase because you’re already at the top of your band.

HR Tactic #4: They’re Secretly Hoping You’ll Negotiate (But Most People Don’t)

Here’s the tactic that surprises most employees: 73% of employers actually expect candidates to negotiate salary, according to recent negotiation research. Yet 55% of workers don’t even try.

This creates a fascinating dynamic. Your manager has likely been given a range, not a fixed number. They might offer you £55,000 knowing they have approval to go up to £60,000 if you push back. They’re testing to see if you know your worth.

What your boss is really thinking: “I’ve offered £55,000, but I have authorisation up to £58,000. If they accept immediately, great, I’ve saved the company £3,000. If they negotiate professionally, I’ll respect that and probably meet them somewhere in the middle.”

The Anchoring Effect in Action

Managers use a psychological principle called “anchoring” where the first number mentioned in a negotiation becomes the reference point for all subsequent discussions. If they offer £50,000 first, you’re now negotiating up from that anchor.

But you can use this to your advantage. Research from the University of Idaho found that candidates who asked for £100,000 received an average offer of £35,383, compared to £32,463 for those who didn’t anchor high. That’s nearly £3,000 more just for setting a higher initial expectation.

The key is to anchor high but reasonably. Don’t say “I think I deserve £80,000.” Instead, try: “Based on my research, professionals with my experience and skills typically earn between £75,000 and £85,000 in this market. Does that align with your budget for this role?”

HR Tactic #5: Your Manager Has Less Power Than You Think (And More Than They Admit)

Here’s a paradox: your manager will often position themselves as powerless in salary decisions, claiming “it’s out of my hands” or “HR sets the budgets.” But research on salary review processes reveals that 41% of companies use a collaborative model where managers can suggest changes to HR recommendations based on additional context.

What your boss is really thinking: “I do have some flexibility here, but I don’t want to set a precedent where everyone thinks they can negotiate. If I admit I can go higher, word will spread, and I’ll have 10 other people in my office tomorrow asking for raises.”

The Manager’s Dilemma

Your manager faces competing pressures:

• Budget constraints from finance
• Equity concerns from HR (ensuring fair pay across the team)
• Retention worries (losing you would be expensive and disruptive)
• Team morale (if they give you a huge raise, others might feel undervalued)

Understanding these pressures helps you frame your negotiation in terms that address their concerns, not just your wants.

HR Tactic #6: They’re Tracking Your “Flight Risk” Score

Modern HR departments use sophisticated analytics to predict which employees are likely to leave. They track factors like:

• Time since last promotion
• Salary position relative to market
• Engagement survey responses
• LinkedIn activity and profile updates
• Participation in company events
• One-on-one meeting frequency with managers

If you’re flagged as a flight risk, you suddenly become a priority for retention efforts, including salary increases. According to workforce insights data, August 2024 saw the highest turnover rates of the year at 3.2% in the US, with many companies scrambling to retain talent during this period.

What your boss is really thinking: “The HR dashboard shows that employees in Sarah’s salary range and tenure typically leave within six months if they don’t receive a meaningful increase. I can’t afford to lose her right now with the project deadline approaching.”

The Competing Offer Strategy

Here’s where it gets tactical. Having a competing job offer dramatically increases your negotiating power, but you must handle it carefully. Research shows that 85% of Americans who negotiated their salary received at least part of what they requested.

However, presenting a competing offer as an ultimatum can backfire. Instead, frame it as a difficult decision you’re facing: “I’ve received an offer for £70,000 from another company, but I genuinely prefer to stay here because of the team and the work we’re doing. Is there any flexibility in the current offer that might help me make this decision?”

HR Tactic #7: The “Total Compensation” Redirect

When managers can’t or won’t increase your base salary, they’ve been trained to redirect the conversation to “total compensation.” This includes:

• Performance bonuses
• Stock options or equity
• Additional holiday days
• Flexible working arrangements
• Professional development budgets
• Health and wellness benefits

What your boss is really thinking: “I genuinely can’t go higher on base salary right now, but if I can offer her an extra week of holiday and a £2,000 training budget, that might be enough to keep her happy until the next review cycle.”

The Hidden Value Calculation

Before your salary review, calculate your total compensation package, not just your base salary. According to compensation review guidance, companies increasingly focus on total rewards packages rather than salary alone.

Create a spreadsheet that includes:

• Base salary
• Annual bonus (if applicable)
• Employer pension contributions
• Private health insurance value
• Stock options or equity (calculate current value)
• Additional benefits (gym membership, phone allowance, etc.)

This gives you a complete picture and helps you evaluate whether non-salary increases are genuinely valuable or just a distraction tactic.

HR Tactic #8: They’re Using a Merit Matrix You’ve Never Seen

Most companies use a tool called a “merit matrix” that combines your performance rating with your position in the salary band to determine your raise percentage. It looks something like this:

What your boss is really thinking: “According to the merit matrix, someone with a ‘meets expectations’ rating who’s already paid above market rate only qualifies for a 2% increase. But I know that won’t feel meaningful to them after a year of solid work.”

How to Work the Matrix in Your Favour

If you can demonstrate that you deserve a higher performance rating or that you’re actually below market rate (using your own research), you can shift yourself into a different cell of the matrix, potentially doubling or tripling your raise percentage.

This is why doing your homework before the salary review is crucial. Come armed with:

• Specific examples of exceptional performance
• Market salary data for your role and location
• Evidence of expanded responsibilities
• Quantifiable business impact you’ve created

What You Can Do With This Inside Knowledge

Now that you understand the tactics your boss is using, here’s how to prepare for your next salary review:

Three Months Before Your Review

• Document your achievements throughout the year, not just in the week before your review
• Research market rates for your role using sites like Glassdoor, PayScale, and industry-specific salary surveys
• Update your LinkedIn profile (yes, HR is watching, and it signals you’re aware of your market value)
• Request feedback regularly from your manager so there are no surprises during the formal review

One Month Before Your Review

• Schedule a pre-review conversation with your manager to understand their perspective on your performance
• Prepare your case with specific examples of how you’ve exceeded expectations
• Calculate your total compensation to understand the complete picture
• Determine your target number and your walk-away number

During the Salary Review

• Let them make the first offer to avoid anchoring yourself too low
• Ask questions about how the decision was made and what factors were considered
• Request time to consider if the offer is lower than expected rather than accepting immediately
• Focus on value, not need (don’t say “I need more money because my rent increased”; say “Based on my contributions and market research, I believe a salary of £X reflects the value I bring”)

After the Salary Review

• Get everything in writing, including the new salary, effective date, and any additional benefits discussed
• If the answer is no, ask what specific goals you need to achieve for a raise in six months
• Consider your options honestly if the gap between your worth and their offer is significant

The Uncomfortable Truth About Salary Reviews

Here’s what most career advice won’t tell you: sometimes, the best salary increase comes from changing jobs, not from internal reviews. Research consistently shows that the largest raises typically come from switching employers rather than climbing the ladder at one company.

If you’ve been at your company for several years without significant increases, you may have hit what’s called the “loyalty penalty.” Your salary is based on what you were hired at, plus modest annual increases, whilst new hires in similar roles are brought in at current market rates.

What your boss is really thinking: “I know Sarah is underpaid compared to the new hire we just brought in for a similar role, but my hands are tied by the salary review budget. I’m worried she’ll find out and leave.”

When to Stay and When to Go

Stay and negotiate if:

• You’re genuinely valued and your manager advocates for you
• The company is growing and creating new opportunities
• You’re learning and developing valuable skills
• The total compensation package (including non-salary benefits) is competitive
• You have a clear path to promotion within 12-18 months

Consider looking elsewhere if:

• You’ve been passed over for raises multiple times despite strong performance
• Your salary is more than 15% below market rate with no plan to correct it
• The company is struggling financially with no clear turnaround plan
• You’ve stopped learning and growing in your role
• Your manager can’t or won’t advocate for your advancement

The Future of Salary Reviews

The landscape of compensation reviews is changing rapidly. Pay transparency laws are expanding across Europe and North America, with about 15 states in the US expected to have pay transparency requirements.

This means companies will increasingly be required to disclose salary ranges in job postings and potentially to current employees. This shift gives workers unprecedented access to information that was previously closely guarded by HR departments.

Additionally, more companies are moving from annual to biannual or even quarterly compensation reviews to stay competitive in fast-moving talent markets. This creates more opportunities for you to negotiate and adjust your compensation based on your contributions and market changes.

Your Action Plan for the Next Salary Review

Understanding what your boss really thinks during salary reviews isn’t about manipulation, it’s about informed negotiation. When you know the systems, budgets, and pressures that shape compensation decisions, you can have more productive conversations that lead to fair outcomes.

Remember these key insights:

• The budget was set months ago, but there’s usually flexibility within ranges
• Your performance was calibrated against colleagues, so exceptional work matters
• Market data drives decisions more than you might think
• Most employers expect negotiation, so don’t leave money on the table
• Your manager has constraints but also more discretion than they might admit
• Flight risk matters, and companies will pay to retain valuable employees
• Total compensation includes more than just base salary
• Merit matrices determine raises, but you can influence your position in them

The most important thing? Don’t wait until the salary review to start this process. The employees who get the best outcomes are those who manage their careers proactively, document their achievements continuously, and understand their market value long before they sit down for that crucial conversation.

Your next salary review doesn’t have to be a source of anxiety. Armed with these insider tactics, you can walk into that meeting room with confidence, knowing exactly what your boss is thinking and how to navigate the conversation to achieve the compensation you deserve.

The power dynamic in salary reviews isn’t as one-sided as it appears. Now that you know the tactics, it’s time to use them.

Read also: Top 7 Healthcare Jobs in Demand in the UK (2025): Salary Insights & Career Opportunities